| Year |
Semifinal |
Championship |
| 2002 |
Illinois Wesleyan 1, Elmhurst 0 |
Wheaton 2, Illinois Wesleyan 1 |
| 2003 |
Illinois Wesleyan 0, Augustana 0
(Augstana advanced 2-0 on penalty kicks) |
-- |
| 2004 |
Illinois Wesleyan 4, Carthage 1 |
Wheaton 5, Illinois Wesleyan 1 |
| 2005 |
Illinois Wesleyan 3, Augustana 1 |
Wheaton 4, Illinois Wesleyan 0 |
| 2006 |
Illinois Wesleyan 3, Augustana 3
(Augustana advanced 7-6 on penalty kicks) |
-- |
| 2007 |
Wheaton 3, Illinois Wesleyan 2 (OT) |
-- |
| 2008 |
Illinois Wesleyan 1, Carthage 0 |
Wheaton 1, Illinois Wesleyan 0 |
| 2009 |
Illinois Wesleyan 1, Wheaton 1
(IWU advanced 4-1 on penalty kicks) |
Augustana 1, Illinois Wesleyan 0 |
| 2010 |
Illinois Wesleyan 1, Augustana 1
(IWU advanced 5-4 on penalty kicks) |
Illinois Wesleyan 0, Wheaton 0
(IWU wins 3-1 on penalty kicks) |
| 2011 |
Illinois Wesleyan 2, Elmhurst 1 (2 OT) |
Wheaton 2, Illinois Wesleyan 2
(Wheaton wins 7-6 on penalty kicks) |
| 2012 |
Wheaton 3, Illinois Wesleyan 2 (OT) |
-- |
| 2013 |
Carthage 1, Illinois Wesleyan 1
(Carthage advanced 4-2 on penalty kicks) |
-- |
| 2014 |
Illinois Wesleyan 2, Augustana 0 |
Wheaton 1, Illinois Wesleyan 0 |
| 2015 |
Illinois Wesleyan 6, Carthage 2 |
Wheaton 1, Illinois Wesleyan 0 |
| 2016 |
Illinois Wesleyan 1, Carroll 1
(IWU advanced 4-3 on penalty kicks) |
Illinois Wesleyan 2, Wheaton 1 |
| 2017 |
Illinois Wesleyan 2, Carroll 1 |
Wheaton 1, Illinois Wesleyan 0 |
| 2018 |
Illinois Wesleyan 2, Augustana 1 |
Illinois Wesleyan 1, Wheaton 1
(IWU wins 5-4 on penalty kicks) |
| 2019 |
Illinois Wesleyan 1, North Central 0 |
Illinois Wesleyan 1, Augustana 0 (OT) |
| 2021 |
North Central 6, Illinois Wesleyan 3 |
-- |
| 2022 |
Illinois Wesleyan 4, Carroll 0 |
Illinois Wesleyan 4, North Central 1 |
| 2023 |
Carroll 3, Illinois Wesleyan 0 |
-- |
| 2025 |
Wheaton 1, Illinois Wesleyan 1
(Wheaton advanced 4-3 on penalty kicks) |
-- |
